When Community Space FailsArchitects often design shared space with a simple hope:if people encounter one another more often, a community will form.But circulation is not the same as community.In Unité d’Habitation, Le Corbusier’s internal “streets” were intended to create social interaction within a vertical city. Yet circulation that appears communal on a diagram may become inconvenient for families with young children or people who move through space differently.Robin Hood Gardens pushed a similar idea further with its “streets in the sky.” The elevated galleries were supposed to reproduce the social life of a traditional street.But what happens when the gallery does not really function as a street—and the private balconies and courtyards are not enough either?Pruitt-Igoe reveals another problem.A shared space does not only need to be designed. It needs to be maintained.When responsibility for corridors, elevators, or common areas belongs vaguely to “everyone,” it can quickly belong to no one. Poor maintenance and sanitation then become spatial problems as much as managerial ones.These examples suggest that the equity of communal space depends on more than access.It also depends on usability, different bodies and family structures, maintenance, and responsibility.A public space can look generous in plan and still fail the people who use it every day.Perhaps the real question is not:“Does this design create interaction?”but:“What kind of interaction does it make possible, for whom, and at what cost?”Shared space requires not only access, but responsibility.Image: Pruitt-Igoe public housing complex in St. Louis, shortly after completion in 1956. Photograph: Bettmann/Corbis, via The Guardian.